SHOW vs BOOK DIFFERENCES
Jacob Tierney's adaptation is incredibly faithful to Rachel Reid's books - but faithful doesn't mean identical, and there are some changes that made reading the book alongside watching the show that much more interesting.
This page documents all the differences: Big plot shifts, tiny character moments, all of it. Whether you read the books first or binged the show and now you're curious about the source material, this is your guide to everything that are different between the books and the show, and where to find them.

Sex Scene Sequence
In the book, Shane's bottoming sex scene actually takes place earlier in a hotel room - before the episode 1 Vegas rooftop scene. Jacob adapted it and merged it with the Shane apartment visit scene. Lines like "you come here" "no, you come here" are borrowed from this first hotel room scene.

The Russian Gala
The Russian gala scene - Svetlana, Sasha, all of it - doesn't exist in the book. The book just briefly mentions Ilya is attending a gala. Svetlana in the book is simply a regular hookup in Boston, not an old childhood friend, so she's not in Russia with Ilya at all.

Las Vegas Bathroom Scene
In the book, Shane's only thought in the Las Vegas bathroom scene is being quietly impressed by how much Ilya's English has improved ("it had really come a long way."). Lines like "wow, genetic" and "I read the New Yorker now" are both show additions.

Scott & Kip's Timeline
In the book, Scott and Kip's relationship moves much faster. They meet at Straw+berry in 2017 January, and the Stanley Cup kiss is about five months later in June. The show moves their first meeting all the way back to late 2013, which means the show version of Scott and Kip carries that tension for two to three years before the Stanley Cup kiss.

The Wealth Gap
This one's a significant book subplot that the show leaves out entirely. In the books, the difference in Scott and Kip's financial situations is something Kip actively wrestles with. Two examples: He turns down a $50,000 birthday-gift cheque from Scott to pay off his student debt, and he refused a tailored tuxedo suit for the Equinox gala. It's a whole thread about Kip protecting his sense of independence and not wanting money to complicate what they have.

Scott's Parents
In the book, Scott's mum died when he was 15 (A single mother who worked long hours at a grocery store to afford second-hand hockey gear for him) and Scott's dad completely absent. The show changes this: both of Scott's parents passed away when Scott was 12, and they were hockey coaches.

Watching Shane's Cottage Documentary
In the book, Ilya watches Shane's cottage documentary and Shane doing yoga alone. The show adds Svetlana in the room with him when the documentary is playing, which makes Ilya has to pretend he's not that interested and turn it off half way through.

Expanded Conversation Between Shane & Rose
The conversation between Shane and Rose is significantly expanded for the show. In the book, most of what they discuss is either implied or doesn't happen at all. The show builds it out into a full scene, with only "Under Dark" and the line "Michigan, remember? Winter can't scare me" carrying over from the book.

Svetlana's Role In Ilya's Life
Svetlana plays a smaller role in the book and doesn't appear until chapter 15. She's a long-term hookup in Boston, not Ilya's childhood friend. The show significantly expands her backstory, added multiple scenes with her and Ilya, and strengthen her relationship with Ilya.

Ilya's Father Sickness
In the Tampa All-Star game coming out scene, in the book, Ilya doesn't cry after revealing his father had Alzheimer’s (which is changed to dementia in the show), and Shane therefore doesn't climb onto Ilya to comfort him.

Tampa Bay Hotel Room Conversation
The Tampa Bay hotel room scene is longer in the book. In the show, it ends after Ilya reveals his dad has dementia (changed from Alzheimer's from the book). In the book, they keep talking, and Ilya doesn't cry in that scene. Ilya also mentions that the cross he always wears belonged to his mother, and Shane and Ilya discusses when they could spend real time together, somewhere no one knows them, with Ilya asking "when will I have you for as long as I want?"

Ilya's Russian Monologue
Ilya's Russian monologue doesn't exist in the book. That chapter is written from Shane's perspective, and he doesn't understand what Ilya is saying. The show created the monologue from scratch, and it became one of the most heartbreaking scenes in the season.

Shane's Hookups
In the book, Shane tells Ilya about his hookups when Ilya's in Russia (Same call as the "You wear glasses?"). Shane says that he's had two previous hookups: A big, strong top in Mexico and another guy in LA (and a bunch of disappointed women). The show leaves these out entirely.

Scott's MVP Award
In the book, Kip is there in person when Scott wins his MVP award. In the show, Kip watches from Kingfisher with his friends. Fun fact: the cast's reactions were filmed while they were actually watching Olivia Colman's 2019 BAFTA acceptance speech, but not Scott's speech.
















































































































